New York Pizza Pennsylvania Ave Online Ordering

Our Fresh Dough Basted with a Touch of Oil & Sprinkled Lightly with Garlic, Topped with a Special Blend of Mozzarella, Provolone & Cheddar Cheese, with Fresh Oregano.

Sweet and Spicy Pizza

$14.99

$17.99

$19.99

Marinated chicken or Shrimp, banana peppers, green peppers, mozzarella cheese, Our secret sweet & spicy sauce, Topped with fresh Basil.

Jamaican Hayes

$14.99

$17.99

$19.99

Honey BBQ Sauce, marinated chicken or shrimp, red onions, feta cheese, sweet pepper and mozzarella cheese

	Wings	Back to Top
Mild, Hot, Honey BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Chili Sauce, Sweet & Spicy Plum Sauce and Plain. Served with French Fries

Wings	6 pieces. Bump order up to 20 pieces here.	$5.99	Add

	Appetizers	Back to Top


Manhattan Stix	Fresh dough topped with diced Pepperoni, Garlic sauce and Mozzarella cheese baked in oven and garnished with Oregano, Parmesan cheese, and Rosemary flakes. Side of Marinara sauce included.	$7.99	Add

Bronx Stix	Fresh dough topped with diced Bacon, Garlic sauce, and Mozzarella cheese baked in oven and garnished with Oregano, Parmesan cheese, and Rosemary flakes. Side of Marinara sauce included.	$7.99	Add

Italian Bruschetta	Enjoy our mouth watering, tantalizing Italian Burschetta. 5 Slices of freshly baked French bread, brushed with Pesto sauce,topped with grilled Onions, Tomatoes, and Mozzarella cheese. Side of Marinara sauce included.	$5.99	Add

Breaded Mozzarella	6 pieces breaded Mozzarella with side of Marinara sauce	$5.99	Add

Broccoli Cheddar Cheese Bites	8 pieces broccoli & Cheese with side of Ranch sauce	$4.99	Add

Crab Cake Balls	7 crab balls with side of Tartar sauce	$9.99	Add

Catfish Finger	5 pieces of Fish w ith side of Tartar sauce	$7.99	Add

Fish Nuggets	8 pieces fried fish with side of Tartar sauce	$5.99	Add

Fried Calamari	Authentic Mediterranean food, the fried squid topped with slice of Lemon. Side of Marinara sauce included.	$8.99	Add

Fried Zucchini	Slices of fresh zucchini, breaded and deep fried, and served with our tasty marinara sauce.	$6.99	Add

Hot Banana Peppers	Dried spicy battering served with ranch dressing	$6.99	Add

Jalapeno Poppers	6 pieces with side of Marinara sauce.	$6.99	Add

Mini Burgers	4 grilled Beef patties with American cheese.	$6.99	Add

Macaroni Nuggets	8 pieces with side of Honey Mustard sauce.	$4.99	Add

Portobello Mushroom Fries	6 pieces mushroom with side of Ranch sauce	$6.99	Add

Spinach Artichoke Dip	Spinach & artcichoke creamy dip served with 8 slices of bread	$6.99	Add

Mini Turkey Burgers	4 mini turkey burgers topped with provalone cheese	$6.99	Add

Fried Ravioli	(8 pcs.) Lightly battered ravioli fried golden brown topped with parmesan cheese and served with a side of marinera sauce	$8.99	Add

	Side Orders	Back to Top


Bread Sticks		$2.99	Add

Bread Sticks & Cheese		$5.99	Add

Cole Slaw		$1.99	Add

Corn		$2.50	Add

French Fries		$1.99	Add

French Fries with Cheese		$3.99	Add

French Fries w/Gravy		$2.50	Add

Garlic Bread		$3.50	Add

Garlic Bread & Cheese		$4.50	Add

Macaroni & Cheese		$2.99	Add

Mashed Potatoes w/Gravy		$2.50	Add

Mixed Vegetables		$2.99	Add

Onion Rings		$3.99	Add

Western Fries (Oven Baked)		$2.99	Add

Western Fries with Cheese		$3.99	Add

Sweet Potato French Fries	sweet potatoes fried golden brown and sprinkled with cinnamon and brown sugar	$3.99	Add

Funnel Cake French Fries	Topped with powdered sugar	$3.99	Add

	Wraps	Back to Top


B.B.Q. Chicken Wrap	Grilled chicken w ith BBQ S auce, L ettuce, Tomatoes, Onions and cheddar cheese	$6.99	Add

BLT Wrap	Turkey bacon, L ettuce, Tomatoes a nd Mayonnaise	$6.99	Add

Chicken Caesar Wrap	Marinated chicken w ith Romaine L ettuce a nd C aesar d ressing	$6.99	Add

Vegetarian Wrap	Grilled Onions, Mushrooms, Green peppers, Lettuce and Tomatoes.	$6.99	Add

Mexican Wrap	Santa Fe brown rice, Grilled chicken, Spicy Ranch sauce in a tortilla wrap	$6.99	Add

	Oven Baked Subs	Back to Top
Whole Wheat or Hearthy White Bread. 8in. Sub: $6.99 12in. Sub: $10.99

Cheeseburger OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Cheese Steak OBS	Regular or Chicken. 8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Italian Sausage OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Pepperoni OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Fish Fillet OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Tuna OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Chicken Fillet OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Veal Parmesan OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Chicken Parmesan OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Meatball Parmesan OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Eggplant Parmesan OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Grilled Chicken OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Ham and Cheese OBS	HOT OR COLD. 8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Italian Cut OBS	HOT OR COLD. 8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Turkey Breast OBS	HOT OR COLD. 8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Vegetable OBS	HOT OR COLD. 8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

Turkey Burger OBS	8-inch sub or upgrade to 12-inch. Make it with any free fixings: Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Mayonnaise Pickles, Mustard and Ketchup.	$6.99	Add

	NYP Signature Subs	Back to Top


Spicy Buffalo Chicken Sub	Served with blue cheese dressing, lettuce & tomatoes	$6.99	Add

Club Combo Sub	Ham, turkey, salami, American & Provolone Cheese	$6.99	Add

Gyro Sub	Lamb or Chicken. Served with cucumber sauce, lettuce, onion & tomatoes	$6.99	Add

Italian Cheese Steak Sub	Steak. mushrooms, green peppers, onions & marinara sauce	$6.99	Add

NY Special Sub	Turkey, ham, pepperoni & Provolone cheese	$6.99	Add

Philly Cheese Sub	Steak, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo	$6.99	Add

	NYP Signature Burgers	Back to Top
Make it to perfection. Add Chips & Can Soda for $1.99. Please indicate soda type in request field.

Cheeseburger	Grilled Beef with Mayonnaise, American cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes and Onions.	$6.99	Add

Fish Burger	Breaded F lounder w ith Mayonnaise, American cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes and Onions	$6.99	Add

Turkey Burger	Grilled Turkey patties with Mayonnaise, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes and Onions.	$6.99	Add

Chicken Burger	Fried chicken patties with Mayonnaise, Lettuce, Tomatoes and Onions.	$6.99	Add

	Calzones	Back to Top
Well baked crescent shaped fresh dough, stuffed with Mozzarella cheese, in House pizza sauce and your choice of Veggies or Meats and brushed with beaten eggs. Garnished with Oregano, Parmesan cheese and Rosemary flakes. Side of Marinara sauce included.

Cheese Calzone	House sauce and Mozzarealla cheese	$8.99	Add

Veggilicious Calzone	House sauce , tomato, onion, green pepper, black olive, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese	$11.99	Add

Meat Lover Calzone	House sauce , pepperoni, Turkey Ham, Italian Sausage, Ground Beef and mozzarella cheese	$13.99	Add

Steak and Cheese Calzone	House sauce , pepperoni, Turkey Ham, Italian Sausage, Ground Beef and mozzarella cheese	$11.99	Add

	Salads	Back to Top
Regular size or upgrade to a large. Dressings: Italian, Blue cheese, Ranch, Thousand Islands, Italian House, French, Honey Mustard, Greek and Caesar.

Garden Salad	Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Green peppers, Black Olives, Cucumbers and pepperoncini.	$4.99	Add

Buffalo Chicken Salad	Same as the garden salad with Buffalo Chicken.	$6.99	Add

Chef Salad	Same as the garden salad with boiled Egg, Ham, Turkey, American and Provolone cheese.	$6.99	Add

Greek Salad	Same as the Garden salad with Feta Cheese	$6.99	Add

Italian Salad	Same as the Garden salad with Ham, Salami and Provolone cheese	$6.99	Add

Grilled Chicken Salad	Basic garden salad with Grilled Chicken	$6.99	Add

Tuna Salad	Same as the garden salad with Tuna	$6.99	Add

Shrimp Salad	Same as the garden salad with Grilled Shrimp	$7.99	Add

Caesar Salad	Romaine lettuce, croutons and shredded parmesan, caesar dressing.	$4.99	Add

Caesar Salad w/Chicken	Romaine lettuce, croutons and shredded parmesan, caesar dressing. With chicken.	$6.99	Add

Caesar Salad w/Shrimp	Romaine lettuce, croutons and shredded parmesan, caesar dressing. With shrimp.	$7.99	Add

	Grill and Platters	Back to Top


T-Bone Steak	Tender and flavorful, of course it	$16.99	Add

Rib Eye Steak (14oz.)	A 14-ounce tender & juicy cut served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Steak sauce included. Substitute French Fries with any one of the sides Coleslaw, Corn, Mixed Vegetables, Marconi & Cheese and Mashed Potatoes w/gravy.	$14.99	Add

Roasted Chicken		$9.99	Add

Fried Chicken	4 pieces of f ried C hicken a nd Fries	$9.99	Add

BBQ Popcorn Chicken	Breaded Chicken with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of BBQ Sauce included.	$8.99	Add

Chicken Tenders	Long breaded and fried boneless Chicken with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Honey Mustard sauce included.	$9.99	Add

Chicken Nuggets	Tender, juicy chicken nuggets served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Honey Mustard included.	$7.99	Add

	Entrees	Back to Top
Choose your favorite Pasta Entrees and add your toppings.

Pasta Marinara	Choose Spaghetti, Fettuccine or Penne Pasta	$8.99	Add

Stuffed Shells		$9.99	Add

Lasagna		$9.99	Add

	NYP Signature Pasta	Back to Top


Fettuccine Alfredo	Make it to perfection for only $1.99 each. Choose from: Chicken, Sausage, Mushroom, Shrimp, Broccoli.	$9.99	Add

Cheese Ravioli	Make it to perfection for only $1.99 each. Choose from: Chicken Parmesan, Meat Sauce, Meatball, Mushroom, Sausage, Shrimp, Broccoli, Spinach	$9.99	Add

	Gourmet Seafood	Back to Top


Salmon Grilled	Good size of freshly grilled marine salmon with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Slice of fresh lemon included. Substitute French Fries with any one of the sides Coleslaw, Corn, Mixed Vegetables, Marconi & Cheese and Mashed Potatoes w/gravy	$10.99	Add

Salmon Baked	Good size of freshly baked marine salmon with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Slice of fresh lemon included. Substitute French Fries with any one of the sides Coleslaw, Corn, Mixed Vegetables, Marconi & Cheese and Mashed Potatoes w/gravy	$10.99	Add

Crusted Tilapia	2 pieces - Served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce included. Substitute French Fries with any one of the sides Coleslaw, Corn, Mixed Vegetables, Marconi & Cheese and Mashed Potatoes w/gravy.	$12.99	Add

Fried Flounder	2 pieces- Served with French Fries Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce included.	$10.99	Add

Flounder Stuffed with Crabmeat	2 pieces- Served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce included. Substitute French Fries with any one of the sides Coleslaw, Corn, Mixed Vegetables, Marconi & Cheese and Mashed Potatoes w/gravy.	$10.99	Add

Catfish Fingers	8 pieces- Served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce included	$10.99	Add

Coconut Popcorn Shrimp	Lightlt breaded. Served w ith French Fries, lettuce, t omotoes and onion w ith a s ide of Cocktail sauce	$10.99	Add

Fried Shrimp Platter	8 pieces- Served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Cocktail sauce included.	$9.99	Add

Crab Cake Balls	10 pieces- Served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce included.	$12.99	Add

Fried Scallops	10 pieces- Served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce included.	$10.99	Add

Seafood Combo	3 pieces of Shrimp, 1 piece of Flounder Fish, 3 Crab Balls and 3 pieces of breaded Scallops served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Tartar sauce and Cocktail sauce.	$15.99	Add

Wahoo Tenderloin	Golden strips of wahoo fish. Served w ith French Fries, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and a side of tartar sauce.	$10.99	Add

Eggplant Platter	Fried Eggplant served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Side of Marinara sauce included.	$8.99	Add

	Beverages	Back to Top


Soda Can		$0.90	Add

Soda - 20 oz.		$1.75	Add

Soda - 2Liters		$2.80	Add

Juice	Ever Fresh Juices	$1.99	Add

	Desserts	Back to Top


Banana Split Cake		$3.99	Add

Brownie		$3.99	Add

Big Chocolate Cake		$6.99	Add

Carrot Cake		$3.99	Add

Cheese Cake		$2.99	Add

Oreo Cheese Cake		$2.99	Add